Thanksgiving has come and gone, but the battle for favorite holiday pies is still fresh. A recent Google analysis reveals which pies took the top spot in each state, showcasing regional favorites that make Thanksgiving dessert tables uniquely American.
From pumpkin to apple and even haupia, see which pies were crowned the holiday champions across the U.S.
1. Alabama – Pumpkin Pie
Despite being in the heart of the South where sweet potato pie often reigns supreme, Alabamians show a stronger preference for traditional pumpkin pie in their holiday searches.
Local bakeries across the state report pumpkin pie orders increasing by 300% during the Thanksgiving season.
2. Alaska – Pumpkin Pie
In America’s northernmost state, where hardy crops like pumpkins can actually thrive during the short growing season, pumpkin pie tops search rankings. Many Alaskan bakers incorporate local ingredients like wild berries as garnishes to add a unique regional twist.
3. Arizona – Apple Pie
Desert dwellers in Arizona overwhelmingly search for apple pie recipes during the holiday season. Local cooking schools note that higher-altitude baking adjustments are crucial for achieving the perfect apple pie crust in this southwestern state.
4. Arkansas – Pumpkin Pie
Arkansas residents heavily favor pumpkin pie in their holiday searches, maintaining traditional Thanksgiving flavors. The state’s numerous pumpkin patches and fall festivals help cultivate this preference through seasonal activities and fresh ingredients.
5. California – Apple Pie
Drawing from its extensive apple-growing regions like Julian and Sebastopol, California’s preference for apple pie reflects its agricultural heritage. The state’s orchards produce over 2.5 billion pounds of apples annually, making fresh ingredients readily available for holiday baking.
6. Colorado – Apple Pie
Mountain state residents gravitate towards classic apple pie during Thanksgiving preparations. Across high-altitude bakeries, special adjustments to baking temperatures and moisture levels create the perfect flaky crust at elevations above 5,000 feet.
7. Connecticut – Apple Pie
New England’s apple heritage shines through in Connecticut’s pie preferences during the holiday season. Generations of family recipes passed down through Connecticut’s historic orchards contribute to this enduring tradition.
8. Delaware – Apple Pie
First State residents overwhelmingly search for apple pie recipes as Thanksgiving approaches. Rich agricultural traditions from Delaware’s farming communities maintain strong connections to apple cultivation and pie-making.
9. Florida – Pumpkin Pie
Sunshine State inhabitants surprisingly favor pumpkin pie over tropical fruit varieties during the holiday season. Within Florida’s unique climate, bakers have developed special techniques for achieving perfect pumpkin pie consistency despite high humidity levels.
10. Georgia – Apple Pie
Georgia’s preference for apple pie reflects the state’s significant apple-growing industry in the northern mountains. Along the Appalachian region, orchards dating back generations influence local baking traditions during holiday seasons.
11. Hawaii – Haupia Pie
Standing apart from mainland traditions, Hawaii uniquely embraces haupia pie, a coconut-based dessert, as its most-searched Thanksgiving option. Blending Pacific Island flavors with American holiday customs, Hawaiian bakers often incorporate local vanilla and fresh coconut into their haupia creations.
12. Idaho – Apple Pie
Famous for potatoes, Idaho residents actually prefer apple pie during Thanksgiving celebrations. Among the state’s diverse agricultural regions, apple orchards flourish alongside potato fields, providing fresh ingredients for holiday baking.
13. Illinois – Apple Pie
Prairie State searches heavily favor apple pie during the holiday season. Professional bakeries throughout Illinois report that locally sourced apples from Michigan and Wisconsin enhance their Thanksgiving pie offerings.
14. Indiana – Apple Pie
Holiday cooking classes across Indianapolis report record enrollment for apple pie workshops. Social media influencers from the Hoosier state drive viral trends with creative apple pie variations.
15. Iowa – Pumpkin Pie
County fair competitions showcase innovative pumpkin pie recipes each harvest season. Rural communities organize pumpkin-themed baking contests leading up to Thanksgiving.
16. Kansas – Apple Pie
University culinary programs report increasing student interest in artisanal apple pie techniques. Local food bloggers popularize fusion recipes combining wheat state grains with traditional apple pie crusts.
17. Kentucky – Pumpkin Pie
Bourbon distilleries host annual pumpkin pie competitions with distinctive spirit-infused entries. Professional pastry chefs throughout Louisville experiment with aged barrel spices in their pumpkin creations.
18. Louisiana – Pumpkin Pie
French Quarter bakeries blend Creole seasonings into traditional pumpkin pie recipes. Culinary schools across New Orleans teach students to incorporate local flavors into holiday classics.
19. Maine – Apple Pie
Coastal bed-and-breakfasts compete for recognition of their signature apple pie recipes. Food magazines regularly feature Maine’s distinctive take on this holiday classic.
20. Maryland – Apple Pie
Waterfront restaurants along the Inner Harbor showcase sophisticated apple pie variations. Baltimore’s food scene embraces modern interpretations of this traditional dessert.
21. Massachusetts – Apple Pie
Culinary tourism drives interest in regional apple pie variations throughout the state. Popular food trucks specialize in creative interpretations of classic apple pie recipes.
22. Michigan – Apple Pie
Cooking channel features highlight unique Michigan-style apple pie preparations. Local celebrities share treasured family recipes during holiday television specials.
23. Minnesota – Apple Pie
Mall of America cooking demonstrations spotlight innovative apple pie techniques. Popular food festivals celebrate the fusion of Scandinavian and American pie-making traditions.
24. Mississippi – Sweet Potato Pie
Standing apart from the apple-pumpkin dominance, Mississippi embraces sweet potato pie as its most-searched Thanksgiving dessert. Rich cultural traditions throughout Delta communities have preserved this distinctly Southern recipe through generations.
25. Missouri – Apple Pie
Gateway State searches reveal a strong preference for apple pie during Thanksgiving preparations. Proud heritage orchards nestled in Missouri’s rolling hills produce ideal pie-making varieties.
26. Montana – Apple Pie
Big Sky Country residents overwhelmingly search for apple pie recipes despite challenging growing conditions. Adaptable apple varieties developed for northern climates flourish in Montana’s protected valleys.
27. Nebraska – Pumpkin Pie
Cornhusker State inhabitants favor pumpkin pie amidst vast agricultural landscapes. Regional bakeries throughout Nebraska report pumpkin pie sales tripling during November.
28. Nevada – Apple Pie
Desert state Nevada surprisingly favors apple pie for Thanksgiving celebrations. Innovative high-altitude growing techniques in northern regions enable local apple production.
29. New Hampshire – Apple Pie
Granite State searches heavily lean toward apple pie during holiday planning. Centuries-old orcharding traditions influence modern New Hampshire baking preferences.
30. New Jersey – Apple Pie
Garden State residents predominantly search for apple pie recipes as Thanksgiving approaches. Multi-generational farms across New Jersey maintain apple varieties specifically cultivated for pie-making.
31. New Mexico – Pumpkin Pie
Land of Enchantment residents prefer traditional pumpkin pie despite the state’s chile-infused cuisine. Innovative bakers throughout New Mexico sometimes incorporate local pinon nuts as garnish.
32. New York – Apple Pie
Empire State searches strongly favor apple pie, reflecting its position as a major apple producer. Renowned orchards across the Hudson Valley supply premier baking varieties.
33. North Carolina – Apple Pie
Tar Heel State residents increasingly search for apple pie recipes during holiday season. Mountain region orchards provide fresh ingredients for traditional Thanksgiving baking.
34. North Dakota – Apple Pie
Plains state inhabitants demonstrate an unexpected preference for apple pie during the holiday season. Specialized cold-hardy orchards have adapted apple cultivation techniques to withstand harsh northern climates.
35. Ohio – Apple Pie
Buckeye State Google searches reveal apple pie dominates holiday dessert planning. Amish communities across Ohio preserve time-honored pie-making techniques passed through generations.
36. Oklahoma – Pumpkin Pie
Sooner State residents gravitate toward pumpkin pie for Thanksgiving festivities. Modern bakers blend Native American squash varieties into traditional recipes, creating unique regional interpretations.
37. Oregon – Apple Pie
Pacific Northwest dwellers show strong preference for apple pie during holiday preparations. Hood River Valley’s microclimate yields exceptional baking apples prized by local pastry chefs.
38. Pennsylvania – Apple Pie
Keystone State searches highlight apple pie’s dominance in holiday planning. Pennsylvania Dutch influences bring distinctive spice combinations to traditional recipes.
39. Rhode Island – Apple Pie
America’s smallest state makes big claims about its apple pie preference. Maritime climate conditions create ideal growing environments for heritage apple varieties.
40. South Carolina – Apple Pie
Palmetto State residents increasingly turn to apple pie for Thanksgiving celebrations. Upstate orchards supply fresh ingredients while coastal areas adapt recipes for humidity.
41. South Dakota – Pumpkin Pie
Mount Rushmore State inhabitants favor pumpkin pie during holiday preparations. Indigenous squash varieties influence local interpretations of traditional recipes.
42. Tennessee – Apple Pie
Volunteer State searches demonstrate strong preference for apple pie. Smoky Mountain orchards maintain century-old varieties specifically cultivated for baking.
43. Texas – Pumpkin Pie
Lone Star State residents surprisingly favor pumpkin over pecan pie for Thanksgiving. Ranch-to-table movements encourage using locally grown sugar pumpkins for authentic flavor.
44. Utah – Pumpkin Pie
Mormon settlers’ traditions influence the strong preference for pumpkin pie across Utah. Artisanal bakeries throughout Salt Lake Valley incorporate local wildflower honey into their signature recipes.
45. Vermont – Pumpkin Pie
Despite being deep in apple country, Vermonters surprisingly favor pumpkin pie for their holiday tables. Small-scale organic farms throughout the state cultivate specialized sugar pumpkins destined for Thanksgiving desserts.
46. Virginia – Apple Pie
Colonial-era pie making traditions persist in Virginia’s holiday celebrations. Ancient orchards dotting the Shenandoah landscape provide unique apple varieties unavailable elsewhere.
47. Washington – Apple Pie
As America’s apple capital, Washington’s pie preference comes naturally. Sophisticated irrigation systems and volcanic soil create ideal conditions for growing premium baking apples.
48. Washington, D.C. – Apple Pie
Political powerhouses and local residents alike unite in their search for perfect apple pie recipes. Trendsetting restaurants throughout the District reimagine classical preparations with contemporary twists.
49. West Virginia – Apple Pie
Hidden mountain valleys preserve centuries-old apple varieties perfect for pie making. Rural communities celebrate harvest season with time-honored baking techniques passed down through generations.
50. Wisconsin – Apple Pie
Master cheesemakers surprisingly turn their attention to apple pie during holiday season. Award-winning dairy farms supply rich cream for traditional pie toppings.
51. Wyoming – Apple Pie
Rugged landscapes don’t deter Wyoming bakers from mastering apple pie craft. Windbreak-protected orchards in protected valleys yield surprising harvests despite challenging conditions.
Source:
1. Huffington Post
Disclaimer: Some images in this content were created/edited with the help of AI.
Don’t Miss These:
Easy Japanese Dinner: Fluffy Omelet & Edamame Rice
Green Eggs, No Ham: Baked Eggs with Spinach, Leeks & Feta
Spice Up Dinner with South Indian Poached Eggs
Easy Chilaquiles for Dinner with Tangy Tomatillo Salsa
A Flavorful Twist on the Classic Spanish Tortilla Recipe
Golden Tomato Shakshuka with Goat Cheese for Easy Dinners
Quick Sesame Chicken Recipe to Simplify Your Dinner Routine
Seafood Dinner Recipe: Perfect Soft-Shell Crabs at Home
Davin is a jack-of-all-trades but has professional training and experience in various home and garden subjects. He leans on other experts when needed and edits and fact-checks all articles.