10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet

The carnivore diet has emerged as one of the most controversial eating patterns. It eliminates plant foods in favor of an all-animal approach. 

In a survey of over 2,000 participants following this diet for up to 20 months, people reported remarkable energy, sleep quality, and cognitive function improvements.

Before diving into specific recommendations, it’s worth noting that the success of a carnivore diet largely depends on food quality and selection. Making informed choices about which animal products to include or limit can significantly impact your results and overall health experience.

Here are the 10 foods to eat and 10 to avoid with this radical dietary approach.

STOP BUYING GREENS: This Machine Grows $1000s Worth Automatically

โœ“ Set It & Forget It: Fully Automated Growing

โœ“ From Seed to Harvest in Days - No Experience Needed

โœ“ Grow Premium Microgreens Worth $50/lb Year-Round

Note: This is an affiliate link and we may earn a small commission if you purchase at no additional cost. This helps keep our website free to use.

10 Best Foods for a Carnivore Diet

10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet - Carnivore diet concept dp503554814 dnoh
Image Credit: PantherMediaSeller/Deposit Photos

Embracing the carnivore lifestyle means focusing on nutrient-dense animal foods that provide complete nutrition without plant matter. These ten essential foods form the foundation of a successful carnivore diet, each bringing unique benefits and vital nutrients to your plate.

1. Red Meat

10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet - man holding meat carnivore. ss399990991 degm
Image Credit: BublikHaus/Shutterstock

Red meat stands as the foundation of the carnivore diet, offering a rich source of complete protein and essential nutrients. Whether you choose ribeye, sirloin, or ground beef, these cuts provide the sustenance needed for this meat-based lifestyle.

The key is to focus on high-quality cuts and varying your preparation methods. From rare steaks to slow-cooked roasts, red meat’s versatility makes it an engaging staple that can be enjoyed in multiple ways throughout the day.

2. Organ Meats

10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet - Organ Meats ss2177653511
Image Credit: Halil ibrahim mescioglu/Shutterstock

Often called “nature’s multivitamin,” organ meats like liver, heart, and kidneys are nutritional powerhouses that provide unique compounds not found in muscle meat. These traditional foods have been prized by cultures worldwide for their exceptional nutrient density.

Loading newsletter signupโ€ฆ

While organ meats might seem intimidating initially, they can be prepared in ways that make them more palatable. Starting with small amounts mixed into ground meat can help develop a taste for these valuable foods.

3. Fatty Fish

10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet - raw salmon ss1928177690
Image Credit: anmbph/Shutterstock

Fatty fish brings a different dimension to the carnivore diet, offering a lighter alternative to red meat while providing substantial nutrition. Species like salmon, mackerel, and sardines add welcome variety to your meals.

Fatty fish is an excellent choice for any time of day because of its rich, satisfying nature. Whether grilled, baked, or pan-seared, these seafood options help prevent menu fatigue while maintaining strict carnivore principles.

4. Eggs

10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet - Eggs dp154395128
Image Credit: Kruuchenkova/Deposit Photos

Eggs are one of the most versatile foods on the carnivore diet, offering endless preparation possibilities while delivering complete nutrition. From soft-boiled to scrambled eggs, they can be adapted to any meal or snack time.

Beyond their versatility, eggs are an excellent backup option when other animal products aren’t readily available. They’re portable, easy to prepare, and can be combined with other carnivore-approved foods for more complex dishes

5. Bone Marrow & Broth

10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet - Bowl with beef broth dp26772269 dnoh
Image Credit: MKucova/Deposit Photos

Bone marrow and broth provide a luxurious element to the carnivore diet, offering rich flavors and unique textures. These traditional foods can be enjoyed independently or used to enhance other meat-based dishes.

These foods’ warming, satisfying nature makes them particularly appealing during colder months or when seeking comfort food options within the diet’s restrictions.

6. Game Meats

10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet - rabbit meat dp279067330
Image Credit: weyo/Deposit Photos

Game meats bring exciting flavors and variety to the carnivore diet, offering a taste of what our ancestors might have enjoyed. Venison, wild boar, and rabbit each provide unique taste profiles and textures.

These meats tend to be leaner than their domesticated counterparts, requiring different cooking techniques to maintain tenderness. 

The reward is a more diverse and interesting meal plan while staying true to carnivore principles.

7. Low-Lactose Dairy

10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet - butter in fridge dp66696337 dnoh
Image Credit: 8vfanDP/Deposit Photos

Hard cheeses, butter, and heavy cream add richness and variety to the carnivore diet while reducing lactose content. These dairy products can enhance the flavor of other carnivore foods and provide satisfying alternatives.

The key is choosing aged or fermented dairy products with naturally lower lactose content. These options can make the diet more sustainable and enjoyable for those who tolerate dairy well.

8. Poultry

10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet - Raw organic uncooked whole chicken with salt ss615056252 dpdgm
Image Credit: Natasha Breen/Shutterstock

Poultry offers a lighter protein option when you need a break from red meat. Chicken, turkey, and duck provide different flavors and textures while maintaining the all-animal-products approach.

From crispy skin to tender meat, poultry can be prepared in numerous ways to keep meals interesting. The different parts of the bird each offer unique culinary possibilities within the carnivore framework.

9. Animal Fats

10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet - lard in bowl dp33812503
Image Credit: bykofoto/Deposit Photos

Animal fats like tallow, lard, and duck fat are essential components that make the carnivore diet sustainable and satisfying. These traditional cooking fats add flavor while providing the necessary energy.

Learning to render and use these fats can transform your cooking, adding depth to your dishes and ensuring meals are sufficiently caloric and satiating.

10. Seafood

10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet - seafood stew ss2439005307
Image Credit: Darii Sorin/Shutterstock

Seafood adds incredible diversity to the carnivore diet, from delicate white fish to rich shellfish. These options provide different textures and flavors while strictly adhering to animal-based foods.

The variety available within the seafood category helps prevent dietary boredom. From quick-cooking shrimp to meaty tuna steaks, seafood offers numerous options for every meal.

10 Worst Food Choices for a Carnivore Diet

10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet - raw vegetables dp4049246
Image Credit: Xalanx/Deposit Photos

Success on the carnivore diet requires strict adherence to eliminating all plant-based foods and products, no matter how healthy they might be considered in other diets.

Understanding what to avoid is just as crucial as knowing what to eat, as even small amounts of these foods can impact your results and take you out of the meat-based framework.

1. All Vegetables

10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet - fruits and vegetables in supermarket dp151048810
Image Credit: lodtrk.gmail.com/Deposit Photos

Despite their reputation as healthy foods, vegetables have no place in the carnivore diet. This includes all forms – raw, cooked, fermented, or powdered. Even the most nutrient-dense vegetables, like kale, spinach, and broccoli, are completely excluded.

Eliminating vegetables helps reduce potential digestive irritants and anti-nutrients that some believe interfere with nutrient absorption. This strict approach maintains the diet’s core principle of consuming only animal products.

2. All Fruits

10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet - pre cut fruits ss2395328179
Image Credit: septembercloud/Shutterstock

Fruits are strictly forbidden on the carnivore diet, regardless of their natural origin or sugar content. This includes all varieties, from berries to tropical fruits, dried fruits, and fruit-derived products.

The complete elimination of fruits helps maintain the diet’s zero-carb nature and prevents any plant-based compounds from entering the system. Even small amounts of fruit are considered a deviation from the diet’s principles.

3. Grains & Legumes

10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet - green beans ss287802014
Image Credit: leonori/Shutterstock

All grains, from wheat to quinoa, and legumes like beans and lentils are completely excluded. This means no bread, pasta, rice, or products derived from these sources.

This strict elimination extends to all forms of these foods, including whole grains, sprouted grains, and even grain-fed animal products, when possible. The focus remains solely on animal-based nutrition.

4. High-Lactose Dairy

10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet - Milk in various dishes dp24459097 dnoh
Image Credit: Valentyn_Volkov/Deposit Photos

Fresh milk, soft cheeses, yogurt, and other high-lactose dairy products are typically avoided. These foods contain higher amounts of milk sugar and can interfere with the diet’s zero-carb goals.

Even though these foods come from animals, their lactose content makes them unsuitable for strict carnivore dieters. Some people may gradually reintroduce certain dairy products after initial elimination.

5. Nuts & Seeds

10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet - Raw peeled and whole peanut nuts ss2507142215
Image Credit: DenisMArt/Shutterstock

All nuts and seeds are eliminated despite their popularity in other low-carb diets. This includes all varieties, from almonds to pumpkin seeds, and products derived from them, like nut butter and oils.

The exclusion of nuts and seeds maintains the diet’s strict animal-only approach. Even though these foods are often considered healthy, they’re still plant-based and not permitted.

6. Processed Foods

10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet - Sausage and Bean Casserole
Image Credit: Nature of Home

Processed foods, even those containing animal products, have no place in the carnivore diet. This includes commercial sausages, hot dogs, and other manufactured meat products with additives.

The diet focuses on whole, unprocessed animal foods and excludes products with added preservatives, flavors, or plant-based ingredients.

7. Plant-Based Oils

10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet - vegetable oil dp167773508
Image Credit: belchonock/Deposit Photos

All vegetable oils, seed oils, and plant-derived fats are strictly forbidden. This includes common cooking oils like olive, coconut, and avocado, regardless of their perceived health benefits.

The diet relies exclusively on animal-based fats for cooking and flavor. This strict approach eliminates potential plant-based compounds that might interfere with the diet’s goals.

8. Alcohol

10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet - Line of wine bottles dp191579352 dnoh
Image Credit: Valentyn_Volkov/Deposit Photos

All alcoholic beverages are excluded from the carnivore diet, regardless of their source or type. This includes beer, wine, spirits, and even low-carb alcoholic options.

Eliminating alcohol helps maintain the diet’s purity and prevents the introduction of plant-based compounds found in most alcoholic beverages. This restriction supports the diet’s focus on optimal health.

9. Sugar & Sweeteners

10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet - Sugar dp32336157 dnoh
Image Credit: bit245/Deposit Photos

All forms of sweeteners, whether natural or artificial, are prohibited. This includes table sugar, honey, maple syrup, stevia, and all artificial sweeteners commonly used in low-carb diets.

The complete elimination of sweeteners helps reset taste preferences and maintains the diet’s strict animal-only approach. Even natural sweeteners derived from animals, like honey, are typically avoided.

10. Plant-Based Beverages

10 Best Foods & 10 Worst Choices for the Carnivore Diet - coffee grounds tea bag ss295917041
Image Credit: Sukpaiboonwat/Shutterstock

Coffee, tea, herbal infusions, and all other plant-derived beverages are excluded. This strict approach extends to all drinks except water and, in some cases, bone broth.

Eliminating these beverages helps maintain the diet’s purity and prevents the introduction of plant compounds. Water becomes the primary source of hydration, supporting the body’s natural processes.

Source:

  1. ScienceDirect
davin
Website |  + posts

Davin is a jack-of-all-trades but has professional training and experience in various home and garden subjects. He leans on other experts when needed and edits and fact-checks all articles.